HARLEY-DAVIDSON 59596-04BJH Rear Fender Smokey FT04-05

( Brand: Harley-davidson ), ( Manufacturer Part Number: 59596-04BJH ), ( Mounting Holes: Pre-drilled ), ( Type: Rear Fender ), ( Color: Gold ), ( Attachment Type: Bolt-on ), ( Finish: Oem ), ( Placement On Vehicle: Rear )

Review HARLEY DAVIDSON Oem Rear Fender Smokey Gold Black fits SOFTAIL FATBOY FLSTF

The **Harley-Davidson 59596-04BJH FT04-05 Softail Fat Boy (FLSTF) Rear Fender (Smokey)** is a meticulously crafted, high-performance aftermarket fender designed exclusively for the iconic 2004-2005 Harley-Davidson Softail Fat Boy (FLSTF) models. Engineered with precision and built to elevate both aesthetics and functionality, this fender replaces the stock rear fender, offering a sleek, aggressive profile that enhances the bike s bold, low-slung stance while ensuring optimal protection for the rear wheel and drivetrain. Constructed from high-quality, durable materials, the **Smokey** finish delivers a deep, matte black hue with a subtle, textured surface that absorbs light, reducing glare and adding a modern, understated sophistication to the bike s overall appearance. The fender s aerodynamic design minimizes wind resistance, improving stability at high speeds while maintaining the Fat Boy s signature aggressive posture. Beyond its striking visual appeal, this fender is engineered to fit seamlessly with the bike s frame and suspension, ensuring a secure and snug installation without compromising the ride quality or handling dynamics. Whether cruising down a scenic highway or parked in a garage, the **59596-04BJH Smokey rear fender** transforms the FLSTF into a statement piece, blending Harley-Davidson s legendary craftsmanship with contemporary customization options for riders who demand both style and substance.

### **Pros and Cons of Buying a Harley-Davidson 59596-04BJH FT04-05 Softail Fat Boy (FLSTF) Rear Fender (Smokey)**

#### **Pros**

1. **Classic Softail Design** The Fat Boy is one of Harley s most iconic models, blending a low-slung, aggressive stance with a comfortable riding position. The Softail chassis provides a smooth, suspension-enhanced ride without the complexity of a traditional springer.

2. **Strong Engine Performance** The 1,203cc V-Twin (Evo engine) produces **80 horsepower and 88 lb-ft of torque**, which is more than adequate for highway cruising and relaxed riding. The torque-heavy nature of Harley engines makes acceleration effortless, even at lower RPMs.

3. **Comfortable for Long Rides** The Fat Boy is designed with rider comfort in mind. The **ergonomics** including a high seat height (31 inches), wide handlebars, and a relaxed riding posture make it ideal for cruising rather than aggressive maneuvering. The **suspension (47mm rear shock, 12-inch front fork travel)** absorbs road imperfections well.

4. **Low Maintenance Compared to Older Models** While not as modern as newer Harley engines, the **Evo engine (1999 2007)** is more reliable than the earlier Evolution engines. The **oil bath air cleaner** and **mechanical fuel injection** (pre-2004) are simpler than modern fuel-injected systems, though later models (2004 ) have electronic fuel injection.

5. **Strong Secondary Market & Parts Availability** As a well-known Harley model, parts are widely available, and the **rear fender (59596-04BJH) is a common aftermarket upgrade**. The Fat Boy has a dedicated following, meaning you ll find aftermarket support for customization (exhaust, saddlebags, etc.).

6. **Aesthetic Appeal** The **Smokey paint job** (a popular custom finish) adds a unique, vintage-inspired look. The **chrome details, round headlights, and aggressive stance** make it stand out on the road.

7. **Good for Beginners & Experienced Riders** While not as nimble as a sportbike, the Fat Boy is **forgiving for new riders** due to its stability and forgiving handling. Experienced riders appreciate its **relaxed yet commanding presence**.

8. **Potential for Modifications** The Fat Boy is a **great platform for customization**. You can upgrade the **exhaust, suspension, handlebars, and seat** to improve comfort and performance. The **open-frame design** allows for easy modifications.

9. **Resale Value** Harley-Davidsons, especially classic models like the Fat Boy, hold their value well, especially if maintained properly.

10. **Nostalgia & Community** Owning a Harley, particularly a Fat Boy, comes with a sense of **belonging to a motorcycle culture** that values freedom, craftsmanship, and the open road.

---

#### **Cons**

1. **Poor Fuel Economy** Like most Harley-Davidsons, the Fat Boy is **not fuel-efficient**, averaging around **25 30 MPG** in real-world conditions. This can add up over long distances.

2. **High Operating Costs** Harley-Davidsons require **regular maintenance**, including **oil changes, valve adjustments, and suspension tune-ups**. Parts and labor can be expensive, especially if you don t have access to a Harley dealership.

3. **Ride Quality Issues** The **Evo engine can be noisy and rough** compared to modern Harley engines. Some riders report **vibration through the seat**, especially at higher speeds. The **front suspension (12-inch forks) can feel stiff** on rough roads.

4. **Weight & Maneuverability** The Fat Boy weighs around **750 800 lbs**, making it **heavy and less agile** than modern cruisers or sportbikes. Tight parking spaces and city riding can be challenging.

5. **Outdated Technology** Compared to newer Harleys (e.g., **2010 models with electronic fuel injection, traction control, and modern suspension**), the **FT04-05 Fat Boy lacks advanced rider aids**. The **mechanical fuel injection (pre-2004) or early electronic injection (2004 2005) can be less reliable** than modern systems.

6. **Seat Height & Accessibility** The **31-inch seat height** makes it difficult for shorter riders to plant their feet firmly on the ground, increasing the risk of **knee strain or instability** when stopped.

7. **Potential for Rust & Wear** Older Harleys (especially those not well-maintained) can suffer from **rust in the frame, suspension, and drivetrain**. A thorough inspection is **essential before purchase**.

8. **Limited Aftermarket Support for Modern Upgrades** While parts are available, **modern Harley upgrades (e.g., electronic suspension, advanced fuel systems) are not compatible** with this older model.

9. **Noise & Exhaust Restrictions** The **stock exhaust is loud**, and some areas have **strict noise regulations**. Aftermarket exhausts can help, but they may not meet legal standards in all locations.

10. **Depreciation Over Time** While Harleys hold value, **older models depreciate faster** than newer ones. If you plan to sell in the future, a **2004 2005 Fat Boy may not retain value as well as a newer Harley**.

---

### **Conclusion**

The **Harley-Davidson FT04-05 Softail Fat Boy (FLSTF) with the Smokey rear fender** is a **fantastic choice for riders who prioritize classic Harley styling, comfort, and a relaxed cruising experience**. It s well-suited for **long-distance riding, weekend cruises, and those who enjoy the Harley-Davidson lifestyle**. However, it comes with **trade-offs in fuel efficiency, maintenance costs, and modern convenience features**.

If you re looking for a **low-maintenance, reliable cruiser with a strong following and customization potential**, this bike is an excellent pick **especially if you find one in good condition with a clean service history**. On the other hand, if you want **better fuel economy, modern technology, or easier handling**, a **newer Harley (e.g., 2010 model) or a different brand (e.g., Indian Scout, Triumph Bonneville) might be a better fit**.

---

### **Recommendation**

You love the **classic Harley look and feel** and don t mind its quirks.

You plan to **ride mostly on highways and open roads** rather than in tight urban areas.

You re **prepared for higher maintenance costs** and enjoy working on or customizing your bike.

You find a **well-maintained example** with **no major rust or mechanical issues**.

You appreciate **torque, comfort, and the Harley community culture**.

You need **fuel efficiency, modern tech, or easy maneuverability**.

You re **not comfortable with higher operating costs** (oil changes, suspension work, etc.).

You **don t have space or skills** for basic maintenance and repairs.

You **prioritize performance and agility** over classic cruising style.

**Final Verdict:** This is a **great bike for the right rider** one who values **tradition, comfort, and the Harley experience** over modern conveniences. **Get a pre-purchase inspection, check the service records, and ensure the bike is mechanically sound** before buying. If you re in love with the Fat Boy s style and willing to embrace its quirks, it will be a **rewarding and enjoyable ride** for years to come.

Details:

Condition: Used. Has scratches around the bottom edge of fender well in black paint. There are other much less significant small scratches, but this fender will present very well, especially for being 21-22 years old. Includes: Rear fender, as shown in photos.

Has a no dents. DLXHD 042326, HARLEY FLSTF REAR FENDER. I photographed it to show up, but will NOT look anywhere near that noticeable in real observation, once mounted your bike. HARLEY FLSTF REAR FENDER Smokey Gold Vivid Black w/ Burgundy pinstripes, Fits: This paint scheme was used on the '04-05 Fatboy.

part #: 5959604bjh price

• $424.50

specifications febocy:

• for models: Flstf, Softail, Fatboy
• for makes: Harley
• brand: Harley-davidson
• mpn: 59596-04bjh
• mounting holes: Pre-drilled
• type: Rear Fender
• color: Gold
• attachment type: Bolt-on
• finish: Oem
• placement on vehicle: Rear

returns febocy:

• time: 30 Days
• policy: Returns Accepted
• paid by: Buyer

general febocy:

• condition: Used
• Motorcycle Scooter Parts Accessories > Body Frame > Fenders

offer febocy:

• quantity: 1
• started: April 23, 2026
• availability: In Stock
• options: Ship-to-home
• sold: 0

payments febocy:

• other
• wallet: Apple-pay
• credit card: Visa

shipping febocy:

• cost: $35.50
• service: Standard
• type: Fixed
• transit: 2-6 Days
• class: Standard

seller febocy:

• rating: 100.0%
• # reviews: 4723
• city: Claremore, Oklahoma

Harley-davidson 59596-04BJH Is Similar To:

• 310096 Vtwin Harley Davidson Aftermarket Flst Chrome Front Fender Mount (37.8% similar) And or ask your local mechanic. Exact year and model are unknown. Harley davidson aftermarket flst chrome front fender mount twin new old stock. Measurements photos etc. This item is a swap meet special sold as...(April 3rd, 2018)
• 58900107eco 58900107eco Harley Davidson Front Fender (36% similar) Front fender 58900107ECO color olive gold bought it to replace from my 2016 softail slims but the damages done was too much and ended up totaling bike a really nice if you want change looks replacing dent. His is your chance...(December 14th, 2017)
• 59085-04bhy 59085-04bhy Harley-davidson Oem Harley Davidson (40.5% similar) As always, bear in mind that used parts are not new. Some are like new, out of the package, used for mock up or have minor scratches, etc. Oem parts are listed as such. Photos are actual item for sale and will fit what we say they will, but as always do your homework, double check that the part bike...(July 7th, 2017)
• Bf6-16 Oldys Custom Composites To Hugger Style Front Harley Bagger Fender (26.4% similar) BF6-16 baggier huger front fender body 6 wide, also wide at the mounting tabs diameter correct for 16 to 19 tire size hand laid fiberglass construction raw white gel coat finish thick with heavy woven fabric used in tab area holes not pre drilled always test fit before painting...(September 24th, 2018)
• Bf6-23 Oldys Custom Composites Hugger Style Front Harley Bagger Fender Free (28.3% similar) ...(July 16th, 2018)
• 00-13 Harley Davidson Oem Road Glide (31.9% similar) Harley oem front road glide fender with no dents. If your bike is this color the paint have a few chips and scratches but could easily be used as...(March 11th, 2017)
• 00023 Tcb Stretched Harley Davidson 23 (19.2% similar) Fits all touring model's 89-13STREET glide road king Electra ultra classic normal prep work is required prior to painting. More durable then abs plastic. Made of fiberglass. AC133834 this fender is designed to look like a stock front but stretched. How SCLNK1 lt : a : most popular : SW BROWSE2...(February 24th, 2017)
• 000458a Pmbe Harley-davidson 09-13 Harley (37.6% similar) ...(September 13th, 2017)
• 00231 Tcb Harley Davidson 23 Inch (24.1% similar) Come in unfinished black primer. This custom fender is hand laid made from high quality materials to produce a that extremely strong, super durable, and fits great. A: most popular. Please let us know as soon possible by sending a complete of the problem, in order to help process your claim timely ...(February 19th, 2017)
• 0174-1002-b Performance Machine Black Fender Relocation Brackets Wheel Harley Flh (24.3% similar) Performance machine black fender relocation bracket kit includes two brackets does not include hardware for use when running a 21 wheel with stock fits: harley touring FL model's front item fitment: part number: PM0174-1002-B retail: 59...(June 21st, 2018)